RESTAURANTS IN PLAYA POTRERO Where Locals Eat
From morning coffee and classic casados to sunset bars and upscale dinners, these are our local favorites for eating well in Playa Potrero.
Potrero isn't just an incredible spot to launch your scuba diving trips; it's an unexpected foodie destination with a true "little bit of everything" scene. Unlike some resort towns, you'll find a genuine mix here, from local treasures to high-end date night spots. Dinner is where the variety really shines: whether you're craving upscale fine dining, a hearty Italian meal, savory Indian food, or a lively Mexican spot, Potrero has it covered.
BEST DISH RECOMMENDATIONS
For a casual start to your day, grab a coffee and breakfast at great cafes like Carpe Diem or Nita Café. When lunchtime rolls around, swing into a classic Costa Rican spot like Soda Marcell for an affordable, filling casado, or hit up Woodstocks for one of the best bar-style burgers around.
Add in the local craft brewery, several excellent sunset bars, and cozy dinner options, and you have enough variety to eat somewhere new every night of the week. Come ready to explore a culinary scene that's as diverse as the surrounding landscape.
POTRERO BREWING CO.: BEER, FOOD, AND FUN
This is the ultimate local hangout and a must-visit whether you’re a craft beer fan or just looking for a lively, casual night out. Potrero Brewing Co. is Guanacaste's go-to spot for incredible, locally brewed beer. But it’s much more than just a taproom—it's a vibrant food hub! The brewery features a cool setup with three different food truck-style kitchens on site: a Nicaraguan grill for savory meats, a fantastic café for breakfast and coffee, and another spot slinging hamburgers and pizza. You can grab a pint and your meal of choice, settle in for the evening, and enjoy the atmosphere. They regularly host live music and feature big screen TVs for catching up on sports. If you're staying longer, look out for their fun monthly bingo night. Planning a big celebration or retreat? The entire venue is also open for private event bookings.
HEMINGWAYS: UPSCALE BEACHFRONT VIBES
If you’re ready for a fantastic evening right on the sand, Hemingways is your spot. This restaurant defines special dining with a gorgeous beachfront setting, making it the top choice for a memorable date night or a meaningful evening out in Potrero. The atmosphere at sunset is unbeatable, but the best part for our guests is the convenience: it’s the exact same location as Under The Sea Diving! That means you can finish your afternoon dive, walk a few steps, and settle in for a cold beer or a signature cocktail before dinner. Beyond the incredible food and view, they regularly host live music to enhance the atmosphere and run a great monthly Outdoor Market, which is perfect for picking up local crafts and goods. Don't miss this one for a perfect night right on the beaches of Playa Potrero.
SODA ARENAS: THE REAL TASTE OF POTRERO
If you want the absolute best of local Costa Rican cuisine in an atmosphere that can't be beat, you have to find Soda Arenas. Forget the fancy menus—this is a true town favorite, serving up generous portions of the food you actually want to eat here. Known for having Potrero's best Casados (the classic plate of rice, beans, salad, plantain, and your choice of protein) and their incredible Arroz con Pollo (rice with chicken), everything here is fresh, flavorful, and made with love. The setting is pure Pura Vida: an open-air spot where you can soak up the local environment and watch daily life unfold. It’s exactly the kind of unpretentious, delicious, and friendly local gem that makes travel so rewarding.
THE SHACK: COMFORT FOOD AND COLD BEER
Ready to kick back with some serious comfort food? The Shack is a total hit with locals and expats who appreciate a great menu that successfully mixes Tico charm with international favorites. This is your go-to for fantastic burgers, giant plates of nachos, and the best fish-and-chips when you're craving something hearty. But don't sleep on their famous breakfast burritos if you get an early start! Beyond the food, the vibe is purely Pura Vida: a friendly, laid-back spot with plenty of cold beer and a welcoming atmosphere. It’s perfect for fueling up before a big day of diving or just unwinding after exploring the coast. If you’re looking for a simple, delicious, and reliable meal in Potrero, pull up a seat here.
Ready for the Best Scuba Diving in Costa Rica?
From thrilling dive tours to professional PADI certification, our team is ready to help you plan the perfect adventure in Guanacaste — whether it's your first dive or your five-hundredth.